How to Choose Your First Welder: A Comprehensive Guide

So you want try some welding? It can be daunting at first, but welding is a really useful tool to add to your DIY skills. Its much easier than it looks, and like woodworking you just need to get started. I have tried many types over the years and looking back if I was starting out there are a few things I would focus on.

Amazon affiliate and 3rd party links are used on this page and in the lists provided. Please see our full disclosure page for more information.

When starting out in welding, choosing the right type of welder is crucial for your success and learning experience. Stick and flux core MIG welders are generally better choices for beginners compared to other options such as TIG (Tungsten Inert Gas) welding. These types are more forgiving, easier to learn, and versatile for various projects. TIG welding, while highly precise and clean, requires more skill and control, making it less suitable for novices.

Why Stick and Flux Core MIG Welders are Ideal for Beginners

Stick Welding and Flux Core MIG Welding are two of the most accessible welding methods for those new to the craft. Here’s why they stand out as the best options for beginners:

• Ease of Use: Both methods are easier to set up and operate compared to TIG welding, which requires precise control and coordination.

• Versatility: They are suitable for a wide range of applications and materials, including metals that might be dirty or rusty.

• Cost-Effective: The initial investment and ongoing costs are generally lower, making them budget-friendly options.

• Outdoor Capability: Both methods can be used outdoors without the need for shielding gas, which is a significant advantage for many DIY projects.

Understanding Flux Core MIG Welding

Flux Core MIG Welding uses a wire-fed process similar to traditional MIG welding but without the need for an external shielding gas. The flux core wire produces its own shielding gas as it melts, protecting the weld from contamination.

Advantages:

1. Beginner-Friendly: Simple setup and operation make it ideal for those just starting out.

2. Portable: No need for a separate gas tank, enhancing mobility.

3. Versatile: Effective on various metal thicknesses and types.

4. Outdoor Use: Suitable for outdoor conditions where wind might disrupt shielding gas.

Disadvantages:

1. More Spatter: Generates more spatter, requiring additional cleanup.

2. Higher Consumable Cost: Flux core wire is typically more expensive than solid MIG wire.

3. Limited to Ferrous Metals: Best for steel and iron, not suitable for non-ferrous metals like aluminum.

Top Flux Core MIG Welder Options

1. Forney Easy Weld 140 FC-i

   • Features: Lightweight and portable, up to 140 amps output.

   • Benefits: User-friendly interface, versatile for different projects.

   • Price: Around $270.

   • Reviews: Positive feedback for ease of use and reliability.

2. Hobart Handler 100

   • Features: Robust build, up to 100 amps output.

   • Benefits: Durable and reliable for light to medium-duty tasks.

   • Price: Around $400.

   • Reviews: Appreciated for its performance and durability.

Understanding Stick Welding

Stick Welding (Shielded Metal Arc Welding or SMAW) involves using a consumable electrode coated in flux. The electric current creates an arc between the electrode and the metal, which melts the electrode and joins the metals.

Advantages:

1. Simplicity and Durability: Fewer components mean it's easier to maintain.

2. Wide Range of Applications: Suitable for various metals, including rusty or dirty ones.

3. Cost-Effective: Lower initial cost and electrode expenses.

4. Outdoor Use: Performs well in windy conditions without shielding gas.

Disadvantages:

1. Learning Curve: Requires more skill to master due to manual control.

2. Cleanup: Produces slag that must be chipped away after welding.

3. Slower Speed: Generally slower than MIG welding.

Top Stick Welder Options

1. Lincoln Electric K1170 AC225

   • Features: Robust and reliable, up to 225 amps output.

   • Benefits: Affordable and easy to maintain.

   • Price: Around $300.

   • Reviews: Highly rated for its durability and versatility.

2. Hobart Stickmate 160i

   • Features: Lightweight and portable, smooth arc starts.

   • Benefits: Ideal for various welding tasks, user-friendly.

   • Price: Around $450.

   • Reviews: Praised for portability and performance.

Which Welder Should You Choose?

Consider Flux Core MIG Welding If:

• You are a beginner seeking an easy-to-use option.

• You need versatility for various DIY projects.

• You plan to weld outdoors where shielding gas is impractical.

• You prefer cleaner welds with less post-weld cleanup.

Consider Stick Welding If:

• You need a cost-effective, durable welder.

• You plan to weld a variety of metals, including rusty or dirty ones.

• You’ll be working in outdoor environments with wind.

• You’re willing to invest time to master the technique for better control.

Essential Accessories for Your First Welder

You will need accessories! When starting out with welding, having the right accessories can make a significant difference in both safety and the quality of your work. Here are five essential accessories to consider when purchasing your first welder:

1. Welding Gloves:

   • Proper welding gloves are essential for protecting your hands from heat, sparks, and electrical shock. Choose gloves made from durable materials like leather, which offer good dexterity and heat resistance.

   • Top Pick: Tillman 50L Top Grain Leather Gloves.

2. Magnetic Right Angles:

   • Magnetic right angles are invaluable for holding metal pieces at precise angles during welding. These tools ensure your materials stay in the correct position, which is essential for achieving accurate and stable welds.

   • Top Pick: Hobart Magnetic Welding Holder Set.

3. Chipping Hammer and Wire Brush:

   • A chipping hammer is used to remove slag from your welds, while a wire brush helps clean the workpiece before and after welding. Both tools are essential for ensuring clean, strong welds.

   • Top Pick: Estwing Big Blue Welding/Chipping Hammer and Forney Wire Brush.

4. Welding Clamps:

   • Welding clamps are vital for holding your workpieces securely in place while you weld. They ensure accuracy and safety by preventing movement that can lead to poor welds or accidents.

   • Top Pick: Irwin Vise-Grip Original Locking Welding Clamp Set

5. Welding Helmet:

• A high-quality welding helmet is crucial for protecting your eyes and face from harmful UV and infrared rays, sparks, and debris. Look for an auto-darkening helmet, which adjusts the lens shade automatically, providing better visibility and reducing eye strain.

• Top Pick: YesWelder LYG-L500A

Investing in these accessories will enhance your welding experience, improve safety, and help you achieve better results. Remember, quality gear not only protects you but also contributes to the precision and durability of your welds. Happy welding!

Conclusion

Both flux core MIG and stick welders are excellent choices for beginners, each offering unique advantages. The Forney Easy Weld 140 FC-i and Hobart Handler 100 are top picks for flux core MIG welding, providing ease of use and versatility. For stick welding, the Lincoln Electric K1170 AC225 and Hobart Stickmate 160i offer durability and cost-effectiveness.

Consider your specific needs, project types, and willingness to learn when making your choice. With the right welder, you’ll be well-equipped to take on a variety of welding projects, making your introduction to welding both rewarding and enjoyable.

For more detailed comparisons and reviews, you can visit Pro Tool Reviews and This Old House. Happy welding!

Amazon affiliate and 3rd party links are used on this page and in the lists provided. Please see our full disclosure page for more information.